• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Owed Unpaid Wages?

Information for workers owed unpaid wages.

  • Home
  • About
    • Owed Wages?
    • Anatomy of an Unpaid Wages Lawsuit
    • Scholarship
  • News
    • Food Servers
    • Call Center
    • Minimum Wage
    • Off the Clock Work
    • Tip-Sharing
    • Unpaid Commissions
    • Unpaid Overtime Pay
    • Worker Misclassification
  • FAQs
  • Wage Theft
    • 2017 Wage Theft Report
    • “Off the Clock” Work
    • Donning & Doffing Time
    • Minimum Wage Violations
    • Misclassification of Workers
    • Overtime Pay Violations
    • Payroll Debit Card Fees
    • Suspect Record-Keeping
    • Tip-Sharing Violations
    • Unpaid Meal Breaks
    • Unreimbursed Expenses
  • Industries
    • Call Center Agents
    • Food Processing Workers
    • Hotel Workers
    • Non-Exempt Salaried Workers
    • Nurses & Aides
    • Restaurant Servers
    • Roadside Technicians
    • Telecommuters
    • Truck Drivers
    • Construction Project Supervisors
    • Gas Station Workers
    • Residential Property Managers
    • Private Security Guards
  • Contact

Dec 08 2017

The Bank is Closed – Supreme Court Refuses to Review Court Ruling

A group of mortgage underwriters received an early holiday present this year on November 27, 2017, as the United States Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal by their employer Provident Savings Bank FSB. The Bank had appealed a decision by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that the mortgage underwriters were improperly paid a fixed salary for all hours worked, without any overtime pay. Now the Ninth Circuit’s decision will stand, and the underwriters’ case will proceed to trial.

Salary Misclassification in the Mortgage Industry

Like many banks, Provident Savings claimed its classification of its mortgage underwriters as salaried employees was permitted under the “administrative exemption” to the Fair Labor Standards Act. The administrative exemption is intended to apply only to employees whose primary job duties relate to the management of the employer’s business and its general operations.

The Department of Labor and several Courts of Appeals, including most recently the Ninth Circuit in the Provident Savings case, recognize that mortgage underwriters’ core duty of reviewing loan applications using guidelines established by the bank and investors does not count as “administrative.” When mortgage underwriters review loan applications, they are not managing the bank’s internal business affairs. Rather, this service goes to the heart of the service the bank provides to its customers.

The Bank’s Appeal Falls Short

Provident Savings appealed to the Supreme Court, backed by the Chamber of Commerce and all of the other major titans of the banking industry. The banks claimed that mortgage underwriters qualify as “administrative” employees because they have the authority to commit the bank to loans. The lower court rejected this argument, finding that the underwriters’ authority was tightly regulated by the bank’s labyrinthine system of guidelines and checklists regarding the issuance of loans.

The Supreme Court has the discretion to decline to hear an appeal (or to decline certiorari in lawyer-talk). It did so in this case; and as a result, mortgage underwriters and other improperly salaried employees will have the chance to challenge their employers’ use of the “administrative” exemption.

Don’t be fooled by the name. The administrative exemption does not refer to employees whose work is routine or administrative. Quite the opposite. Only employees engaged in the employer’s general business operations can be salaried under the administrative exemption.  On the other hand, employees who are directly involved in the core service their employer provides to customers, like the mortgage underwriters in the Provident Bank case, should receive 1.5 their regular rate of pay for all of their overtime hours.

If you have further questions, the Wage Authority Group is awaiting your call.

 

Image link: https://pixabay.com/en/men-employees-suit-work-greeting-1979261/

Written by Wage Authority Group · Categorized: Worker Misclassification

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Questions? Get Answers

Call: 1-877-739-1127

Or Complete the Following Form:

News

  • U.S. Supreme Court Rules Against Auto Service Advisers In Overtime Lawsuit
  • Lyft Drivers Score Big Settlement As Gig Economy Wage & Hour Lawsuits Continue To Soar
  • Arizona Restaurant Chain Sued for Unpaid Wages
  • Gov’t Employees Sue Cuyahoga County for Unpaid Overtime
  • DOL: Alabama Security Company Withheld Millions in Wages

248-746-4057 Wage Authority Group / Terms ATTORNEY ADVERTISING

© Copyright 2017 All Rights Reserved.